What the Nominees Were: Call Me By Your Name; Darkest Hour; Dunkirk; Get Out; Lady Bird; Phantom Thread; The Post; The Shape of Water; Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
Other Movies That Should Have Been Considered: Really surprising that I, Tonya didn’t get a nomination. The Academy loves biopics, and that was a great one.
What Did Win: The Shape of Water
How It’s Aged: A true oddball win. A very slight, forgettable movie, but a perfectly pleasant way to pass two hours. Whenever I’m trying to conjure up a list of all the Oscar winners, 2017 is one year that stumps me.
How It’s Aged: A true oddball win. A very slight, forgettable movie, but a perfectly pleasant way to pass two hours. Whenever I’m trying to conjure up a list of all the Oscar winners, 2017 is one year that stumps me.
What Should’ve Won: Lady Bird
How Hard Was the Decision: An extremely hard decision between Lady Bird and Get Out, two of my favorite movies. Again, I would love to have declared a tie, but no, a decision had to be made.
How Hard Was the Decision: An extremely hard decision between Lady Bird and Get Out, two of my favorite movies. Again, I would love to have declared a tie, but no, a decision had to be made.
Writer and Director: Greta Gerwig
Stars: Saoirse Ronan, Laurie Metcalf, Tracy Letts, Lucas Hedges, Timothée Chalamet, Beanie Feldstein
Stars: Saoirse Ronan, Laurie Metcalf, Tracy Letts, Lucas Hedges, Timothée Chalamet, Beanie Feldstein
The Story: Christine “Lady Bird” McPherson tries to make it through her senior year (and a bit beyond) at a Catholic school in Sacramento in 2002, fighting with her mom but not her dad. She acts in the school play and starts going out with Danny, but finds him making out with a guy. She ditches her friend Julie for cool girl Jenna and loses her virginity to cool jerk Kyle. Finally, she ditches Kyle just in time to go to prom with Julie as friends. Against her mom’s wishes, she goes to college in New York City, but calls her mom to make peace at the end.
Any Nominations or Wins: It lost everything: Picture, Director, Actress, Supporting Actress for Metcalf and Original Screenplay.
Why It Didn’t Win: It’s not like The Shape of Water was some sort of juggernaut that couldn’t be overcome. Lady Bird didn’t have much momentum either, but really nothing did, so why not go with the best movie? You could certainly make the case that the Academy has a bias against women writer-directors.
Why It Should Have Won:
Why It Didn’t Win: It’s not like The Shape of Water was some sort of juggernaut that couldn’t be overcome. Lady Bird didn’t have much momentum either, but really nothing did, so why not go with the best movie? You could certainly make the case that the Academy has a bias against women writer-directors.
Why It Should Have Won:
- Gerwig got her start as an actress and starred in some films directed by her husband, Noah Baumbach, but when she took her first turn as a solo director, she instantly surpassed his work. (This then inspired him to make his best film, Marriage Story, without Gerwig, about a director married to an actress who then experiences the humiliation of watching her become a director and win awards. Amazingly, Gerwig and Baumbach are still married as of this writing!)
- I saw this movie because I laughed in the trailer when Lady Bird jumps out of her mom’s moving car. It was only later that I realized, “Everything in this movie seems to be auto-biographical, except for that, which she invented to have a good trailer.” And indeed, I later was able to confirm this. Gerwig has said, “I did get out of a vehicle once (during a dispute), but it was a stopped car. The car scene in the movie felt like, emotionally, completely realistic. Everybody knows the feeling of when you’re in a car and you’re fighting, and you want to push them out or you want to jump out, or some combination of the two. You’re literally trapped with the person in the space…I just always knew that’s how I wanted to start the movie.” The lesson: Truth is great, but always have at least one trailer moment that goes bigger than real life.
- In the DVD documentary, Greta Gerwig recounts a conversation she had with Chalamet, after she made him read a lot of political stuff to prepare for the role: “And then he came back and he said, ‘You love this stuff!’ And then we had this whole joke, he was like, ‘The funny thing is that everyone will think that you’re Lady Bird, but actually, you’re Kyle,’ and I was like, ‘It’s true!’ Like when he says that thing about putting cell phones in our brains, I’ve definitely said things like that.” Writers have a lot of humanity in them, and they can’t just save it all up to the give to the hero, they have to gift some to the villain as well.
- Allison Janey was great as the abusive mom in I, Tonya, but Metcalf should have won Best Supporting Actress for this less showy role. She’s great delivering little looks to her daughter that say more than a ream of dialogue. She tells Lady Bird to be a better version of herself, and Lady Bird asks “What if this is the best version?” and Metcalf’s look in response is devastating. She’s also great when she gets to deliver actual body blows in the dialogue, such as “You should just go to City College, with your work ethic. City College and then to jail then back to City College.”






















































